Recently, I have been flooded with calls for help from companies that face failing their initial ISO 9001 or AS9100 simply because they failed to address the auditor’s nonconformities in time. In fact, I’ve had so many of these cases in the last four months that it’s practically become another revenue stream for me. (Listen, I’ll take your money, but this is a problem that really shouldn’t exist at all.)
Here is the scenario: the company undergoes its initial ISO or AS audit, gets a report handed to them, and the auditor leaves. And immediately, key people go on vacation, and folks forget the QMS exists. Meanwhile, there are hardcoded clocks running behind the scenes that mean, no, the audit is definitely not over after the auditor gets back on the plane.
Accreditation and scheme rules require that nonconformities be addressed in a set period of time. For ISO 9001, this is generally determined by the certification body itself. For AS9100, this is burned into IAQG rules that even the CB can’t circumvent. It also gets worse if the nonconformity is major rather than minor, of course.
So, your auditor left? Recommended certification but left you with a few NCs? Here is what you must do:
- On the very next day, on the very next morning, hold an audit finding debrief meeting with the full management team. Ensure that any department manager or process owner who might fall within the scope of each NC is represented.
- Go over each NC and make sure everyone understands everything.
- Review each NC to ensure the auditor hasn’t left anything out, too. Each NC must be supported by three things: an actual citation of an ISO or AS requirement (referencing exact clause number), a full list of evidence examined, and a rationale as to why the evidence shows the requirement was not met. If any of those three are missing, send a request to your auditor and get them to update the NC.
- Write entries in your corrective action system (“CARs,” “CAPAs,” or whatever you call them) for each NC. Yes, you must do this! I am not sure why some folks think they can answer external audit findings outside their CAR system, but you cannot.
- Process each NC in your CAR system. Assign each to a process owner or responsible manager, have them do containment (if necessary), root cause analysis, and develop an action plan. Hold separate meetings for each NC if you have to. Copy and paste the auditor’s finding into your CAR; don’t paraphrase it! If you paraphrase incorrectly, you could waste time fixing the wrong issue.
- For each CAR, make sure the root cause is robust and complete. Don’t restate the problem and frame it as a root cause. You can use the Five Why method, but don’t feel obligated to (literally) ask “Why?” five times. Sometimes you can get to a root cause after three tries; sometimes you may have to ask seven times.
- Make sure your action plan conforms to the CB auditor’s mandatory response requirements. Typically, for ISO 9001 minor NCs, you only have to provide a plan for corrective action, and not actually complete it. In other cases, and especially for major NCs, you will likely have to complete the action before the auditor can release your certificate. Read the fine print on your NC and verify what actions the CB auditor wants and by what date.
- Once you have your internal CARs written, you will notify the auditor. For ISO 9001, you may only need to submit copies of your CARs to the auditor. For AS9100, you must enter your responses in OASIS. Ensure your response in OASIS matches the language on your CAR.
- Submit evidence to support your actions, too. If you updated a procedure, send a copy of the new procedure; if you did training, send training records. You must prove you completed the actions, not just say you did.
- Monitor the auditor’s feedback! In OASIS, the auditor will add notes to each NC. You must log in regularly to check those notes, as many times the auditor will reject your CAR and you have to start over. If you do not monitor this, you will think your actions were fine, and meanwhile your certification will be rejected!
- Auditor not responding? Send an email to your sales contact at the CB. I recommend an email because it leaves a paper trail. People can deny phone calls ever happened (and CBs love to do that). If you know someone higher up the chain at the CB, copy them, too.
- If the auditor still hasn’t responded, yes, you might need to get on the phone. Keep that as a final option. I think you should record the call, but depending on state and national law, you may have to alert the caller that you are recording before they start speaking. Again, CBs love to lie about what happened during a phone call.
If all goes well, the auditor will sign off on your actions and recommend your certificate be released.
But – and here’s a wonky thing that few people outside of the scheme know — the auditor does not issue the certificate. Instead, their report is checked by an independent review committee to ensure all rules were followed and everything is per the applicable standards. Only then can the certificate be issued by the CB. A problem here is that the CB’s review may take weeks, and the clock continues to tick on your certification no matter what. (Yes, this is unfair, but the various bodies have made no attempt to fix this problem.)
So if you take a long time to reply to your NCs, there will be an additional wait period after you get everything signed off by the auditor. Take that into account. The faster you can reply to NCs, the better.
Only when you have your certificate in hand can you truly say that the audit is finished. There are so many things that can go pear-shaped until then.
Now you can go on vacation!
Christopher Paris is the founder and VP Operations of Oxebridge. He has over 35 years’ experience implementing ISO 9001 and AS9100 systems, and helps establish certification and accreditation bodies with the ISO 17000 series. He is a vocal advocate for the development and use of standards from the point of view of actual users. He is the writer and artist of THE AUDITOR comic strip, and is currently writing the DR. CUBA pulp novel series. Visit www.drcuba.world







